Photoshop Generative Fill: The Biggest Change in Photography Since Digital

Editor’s note, November 2026: I wrote this in July 2023, when Generative Fill had just arrived in Photoshop. (I originally called it “Photoshop Generative.” The feature’s actual name is Generative Fill.) The tool has been updated many times since, and Adobe now attaches Content Credentials to AI-generated images, which speaks to some of the concerns below. The ethical questions are still worth asking.

In 2023, photography went through what I think is its biggest change since digital cameras. The cause? Adobe’s new Photoshop feature, Generative Fill. It’s mind-blowing, and here I was thinking Adobe was dead in the water with Midjourney and other AI apps taking over. As an artist, this is fun. As a citizen of the world, it’s concerning.

What Is Generative Fill?

It’s AI built right into Photoshop. You select part of an image, type what you want, and Photoshop creates it and blends it into the photo. It can add things that were never there. It can also take things out, like telephone wires, in seconds. I’ve heard “we’ll Photoshop it” on every shoot I’ve ever been on, and I’ve been on more than 500. This is different. This feels like magic.

Why It Matters

This changes how images get made and edited, and it changes what we mean by photography. Photography has traditionally captured reality. It froze a moment as it existed in the real world. Filters and apps had already chipped away at that.

Original photo of the Waitsfield farmers market

The same farmers market photo edited with Generative Fill to look like a sand trap
A farmers market turned into a sand trap in a few minutes.

With Generative Fill, the line between real and created gets blurry. Any photo might now be part real and part AI, and it’s very hard to tell which part is which.

Half Real, Half Imagined

In a sense, every image edited this way is only half real. For a photographer, that’s a bigger toolbox. You can make a surreal landscape, add dramatic weather, or fill an empty street with a crowd, and it still looks like a photograph.

Below is a photo I shot by Crofter’s Green. I extended the frame, removed the electric wires, then selected the road and added a car’s brake lights and headlights. Three steps, about 15 seconds each.

Original photo near Crofter's Green before Generative FillThe same photo after Generative Fill extended the frame, removed wires, and added car lights

The Ethical Questions

New possibilities, new problems. When you can’t tell what’s real, authenticity and credibility take a hit. What happens to photojournalism? Manipulated images are as old as photography, but the speed and ease are new. Fashion and politics already blur the lines. Want a bigger crowd at your candidate’s campaign stop? You can do it in seconds and post it almost in real time. Photoshop could always do this. Now it’s about twenty times faster and easier.

Adobe and other tech companies have to think this through and build in guardrails. Labeling AI-generated content and keeping a record of edits in the image’s metadata are two possible answers. So far, the race to be first with AI seems to mean figuring out the rules later, or ignoring them until forced.

The Future of Photography

This is more than a software update. It changes how we make, see, and trust images. Every photographer is now also a digital artist, and every image may be a mix of reality and imagination.

Welcome to a new era of photography, where every image might be only half real.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.